Nest i Ecobee dva su najveća imena u areni pametnih termostata. Zapravo, bilo bi vam teško pronaći termostat koji nije jedan od ova dva. 

Obje marke nude brojne prednosti i pogodnosti, ali koja je zapravo bolja opcija – a koja vam najviše odgovara? 

Cijena

Uspoređujući Nest i Ecobee sa stajališta^(Ecobee) troškova, nema jasnog pobjednika. I Nest Learning Thermostat i Ecobee SmartThermostat (najbolje verzije oba modela) koštaju po 250 USD. Ako tražite apsolutne vrhunske performanse, bilo koji od ovih modela je izvrstan odabir.

S druge strane, ako želite uštedjeti nešto novca, možete se odlučiti za niže modele koji još uvijek imaju pametne značajke, ali ne koštaju baš toliko. Na primjer, Google je nedavno objavio novi model Nest termostata^{(new model of the Nest Thermostat)} . Nedostaju mu značajke učenja i nije baš tako pametan, ali također košta 130 dolara. 

Što se tiče Ecobee fronta, možete kupiti obnovljeni Ecobee4 for $190 ili Ecobee3 Lite za 170 USD. Opet, objema nedostaju značajke vrhunskog modela, ali će vam i dalje pružiti osnovnu pametnu kontrolu vašeg termostata i temperature vašeg doma. 

Pobjednik: Neriješeno^{(Winner: Tie)}

Oba uređaja koštaju otprilike isti iznos, ali svaki se više dopada malo drugačijoj publici.

Značajke

Glavni razlog zašto netko ulaže u pametni termostat je smanjenje troškova energije i održavanje udobnijeg doma. Iako će se stvarna ušteda energije razlikovati od modela do modela, i Nest i Ecobee pružaju procijenjene uštede.

Prema Nestu^(Nest) , termostati mogu uštedjeti do 12 posto na računima za grijanje i 15 posto na računima za hlađenje tijekom godine. S druge strane, Ecobee tvrdi da SmartThermostat može uštedjeti i do 23 posto na godišnjim troškovima energije. 

Iako obje ove brojke treba uzeti s rezervom (budući da su obje marketinški trikovi s ogromnim brojem varijabli), postoje i druge prednosti koje treba razmotriti između ova dva uređaja.

Ecobee SmartThermostat

Ecobee SmartThermostat^{(Ecobee SmartThermostat)} može se koristiti za strujanje Spotifyja^{(stream Spotify)} kao i glazbe izravno s vašeg telefona zahvaljujući Bluetoothu^(Bluetooth) . Zvučnik neće impresionirati audiofila, ali nije loš način da imate pozadinsku buku. Također radi s HomeKit^{(works with HomeKit)} -om, funkcionira kao uređaj za telefoniranje i interfon bez upotrebe ruku, te uči i prilagođava se vašoj rutini zahvaljujući Eco+ . 

Ecobee SmartThermostat^{(Ecobee SmartThermostat)} također uključuje SmartSensor u kutiji. SmartSensor je daljinski senzor^{(SmartSensor)} zauzetosti i temperature koji se može postaviti u drugu prostoriju i povezati s termostatom. Na ovaj način, ako u svom domu imate sobu koja nikada ne odgovara ostatku kuće, termostat može automatski prilagoditi svoj izlaz kako bi ta soba bila jednako udobna.

Nest Learning Thermostat

Nest Learning Thermostat ima mnoge od istih značajki kao i Ecobee SmartThermostat^{(Ecobee SmartThermostat)} . Automatski će se isključiti dok ste odsutni radi uštede energije, a njime možete upravljati s bilo kojeg mjesta putem aplikacije Google Home^{(Google Home app)} . Također će dati upozorenja ako temperatura brzo poraste ili padne ili ako otkrije problem s HVAC sustavom.

Nest Learning Thermostat kompatibilan je s 95 posto HVAC sustava, a radi i s Nest temperaturnim senzorom^(Sensor) . Ovaj senzor se može koristiti za praćenje temperature u domu u prostoriji koja se razlikuje od samog termostata. Naravno, Nest Learning Thermostat se također može kontrolirati putem pametnog zvučnika. 

Pobjednik: Ecobee^{(Winner: Ecobee)}

Ecobee ovdje preuzima nagradu zahvaljujući svom širem rasponu značajki i korisnosti. 

Izgled

U moderno doba pametnih kućnih uređaja izgled termostata je bitan. Uostalom, ne možete zanemariti uređaj koji stoji istaknuto na zidu — a ako trošite novac na skupi termostat, trebao bi izgledati bolje od starih četverokutnih termostata koji se danas nalaze u mnogim domovima. 

I Nest Learning Thermostat i Ecobee SmartThermostat dizajnirani su s estetikom na umu. Nest Learning Thermostat je okruglog oblika, s rotirajućim okvirom koji se može koristiti za ručnu kontrolu temperature. To je jednostavan, elegantan dizajn. 

Ecobee SmartThermostat^{(Ecobee SmartThermostat)} ima kvadratniji dizajn sa zaobljenim rubovima i prometnijim središnjim zaslonom. Nešto je veći od Nest termostata^{(Nest Thermostat)} , ali ima futurističkiji izgled. Nema vanjskog okvira, ali ima zaslon osjetljiv na dodir koji se koristi za kontrolu postavki.

Pobjednik: Izjednačeno^{(Winner: Tied)}

Teško je proglasiti pobjednika po izgledu, jer ono što se nekome sviđa na individualnoj razini vrlo je subjektivno. Imajući to na umu, znajte da oba uređaja izgledaju sjajno. Odaberite onu koja najbolje odgovara vašem stilu i ukusu.

Koje je bolje?

Oba glavna pametna termostata su snažne opcije koje mogu poboljšati razinu udobnosti svakog doma. Međutim, Ecobee SmartThermostat pruža više funkcionalnosti i vrijednosti na bazi dolar za dolar. 

Široko je kompatibilan sa sve tri glavne platforme za pametne kuće^{(smart home platforms)} i nudi širok raspon funkcionalnosti koje ga izdvajaju od Nest Learning Thermostata^{(Nest Learning Thermostat)} . Ecobee SmartThermostat^{(Ecobee SmartThermostat)} također ima mogućnosti učenja koje mu mogu pomoći da bolje prilagodi razinu udobnosti vašeg doma. 

U konačnici, predviđa se da će Ecombee donijeti gotovo dvostruko veću uštedu od Nest Learning Thermostata^{(Nest Learning Thermostat)} . Kada se uklone sve ostale značajke i razmatranja, Ecobee SmartThermostat je jasni pobjednik, pogotovo ako imate druge Ecobee uređaje u svom domu. 

Nest Vs Ecobee Smart Thermostats: Which Is Better?

Nest and Ecobee are the two biggest names in the smart thermostat аrena. In fact, yоu would bе hard-pressed to find a thermoѕtat that wasn’t one of these two. 

Both brands offer numerous advantages and benefits, but which one is actually the better option–and which one is the best fit for you? 

Price

Comparing Nest vs. Ecobee from a cost standpoint, there is no clear winner. Both the Nest Learning Thermostat and the Ecobee SmartThermostat (the top-tier versions of both models) are $250 each. If you’re looking for absolute top-of-the-line performance, either one of these models is a great pick.

On the other hand, if you want to save a bit of money, you can opt for lower-end models that still have smart features but do not cost quite as much. For example, Google recently released a new model of the Nest Thermostat. It lacks the learning features and isn’t quite as smart, but it also costs $130. 

On the Ecobee front, you can purchase a refurbished Ecobee4 for $190, or an Ecobee3 Lite for $170. Again, both of these lack the features of the high-end model, but will still provide you with baseline smart control of your thermostat and your home’s temperature. 

Winner: Tie

Both devices cost roughly the same amount, but each also appeals more to a slightly different audience.

Features

The main reason someone invests in a smart thermostat is to cut down on energy costs and keep their home more consistently comfortable. While the actual energy savings will vary from model to model, both Nest and Ecobee provide estimated savings.

According to Nest, thermostats can save up to 12 percent on heating bills and 15 percent on cooling bills over the course of a year. On the other hand, Ecobee claims that the SmartThermostat can save up to 23 percent on annual energy costs. 

While both of these figures should be taken with a grain of salt (as they are both marketing ploys with a huge number of variables), there are other benefits to consider between the two devices, too.

Ecobee SmartThermostat

The Ecobee SmartThermostat can be used to stream Spotify as well as music directly from your phone thanks to Bluetooth. The speaker won’t impress an audiophile, but it’s not a bad way to have some background noise. It also works with HomeKit, functions as a hands-free calling and intercom device, and learns and adapts to your routine thanks to Eco+. 

The Ecobee SmartThermostat also includes a SmartSensor in the box. The SmartSensor is a remote occupancy and temperature sensor that can be placed in a different room and linked to the thermostat. This way, if you have a room in your home that never matches the rest of the house, the thermostat can automatically adjust its output to keep that room just as comfortable.

Nest Learning Thermostat

The Nest Learning Thermostat has many of the same features as the Ecobee SmartThermostat. It will automatically turn itself down while you’re away to conserve power, and you can control it from anywhere through the Google Home app. It will also provide alerts if the temperature rises or drops rapidly or if it detects a problem with the HVAC system.

The Nest Learning Thermostat is compatible with 95 percent of HVAC systems, and it also works with the Nest Temperature Sensor. This sensor can be used to monitor the temperature in the home in a different room than the thermostat itself is in. Of course, the Nest Learning Thermostat can also be controlled through a smart speaker. 

Winner: Ecobee

Ecobee takes the prize here thanks to its broader range of features and utility. 

Appearance

In the modern age of smart home devices, the appearance of a thermostat matters. After all, there’s no ignoring a device that sits prominently on the wall—and if you’re spending the money on an expensive thermostat, it should look better than the old square thermostats that reside in so many homes today. 

Both the Nest Learning Thermostat and the Ecobee SmartThermostat were designed with aesthetics in mind. The Nest Learning Thermostat is round, with a rotating bezel that can be used to control the temperature manually. It’s a simple, elegant design. 

The Ecobee SmartThermostat has a more square design with rounded edges and a busier central display. It’s slightly larger than the Nest Thermostat, but has a more futuristic look to it. There is no exterior bezel, but it does have a touchscreen that’s used to control the settings.

Winner: Tied

It is hard to declare a winner for appearance, as what appeals to someone on an individual level is highly subjective. With that in mind, know that both devices look great. Pick the one that best suits your style and tastes.

Which Is Better?

Both of the mainline smart thermostats are powerful options that can improve the comfort level of any home. However, the Ecobee SmartThermostat provides more functionality and value on a dollar-for-dollar basis. 

It’s widely compatible with all three major smart home platforms and provides a wide range of functionality that sets it apart from the Nest Learning Thermostat. The Ecobee SmartThermostat also has learning capabilities that can help it better adjust the comfort level of your home. 

Ultimately, the Ecombee is predicted to yield almost twice as much savings as the Nest Learning Thermostat. When all other features and considerations are stripped away, the Ecobee SmartThermostat is the clear winner, especially if you have other Ecobee devices in your home. 

Related posts

• Najbolje pametne brave, kamere i termostati za Airbnb domaćine

• Ring vs. Nest vs. Arlo: Koje pametno zvono za vrata biste trebali kupiti?

• Google Home vs Amazon Echo: koji je za vas?

• 7 najboljih igara za igranje s Alexom

• Što je Xfinity xFi? Objašnjeno Comcastovo osobno WiFi iskustvo

• Kako strujati glazbu putem vašeg Amazon Echo

• Bitka za čvorišta pametnih kuća – SmartThings protiv Winka

• Kako izgraditi Ultimate Super Bowl Smart Home Setup

• Amazon Smart Plug ne reagira: 5 popravaka za isprobavanje

• Ultimativni sustav pametnog kućnog kina: kako ga postaviti

• Ultimate Apple HomeKit vodič

• Kako promijeniti jezik Alexa u španjolski i druge jezike

• Kako automatizirati svjetla (i pametna i nepametna)

• Najbolji pametni utikači u 2019. koji rade s Alexa i Google Home

• 6 najboljih Alexa vještina koje pomažu kada ste bolesni

• Najbolje vanjske Wifi sigurnosne kamere za 2019

• Kako koristiti Philips Hue žarulje za svjetlosnu terapiju

• Philips Hue u odnosu na konkurenciju – Koja su najbolja pametna svjetla?

• 5 jeftinih načina da "glupe" uređaje učinite pametnim

• Što učiniti ako vaš pametni asistent ne prepoznaje vaš naglasak